Question 1 · Law, Ethics & Human Factors · Moderate
At 02:00 a district general hospital needs to transfer an intubated, ventilated patient on a noradrenaline infusion to the regional neurosurgical centre. The only doctor free is a core anaesthetic trainee who has never undertaken an inter-hospital transfer, and the unit asks whether the trainee may escort the patient alone. What does the Intensive Care Society and Faculty of Intensive Care Medicine transfer guidance (2019) say about this?
- AYes, provided a consultant is available by telephone throughout and the trainee has read the checklist
- BYes, once a senior clinician has documented a risk assessment accepting the urgency of the transfer
- CYes, if the trainee has completed a transfer e-learning module and the ambulance crew travels with them
- DNo, only a consultant may escort a ventilated patient who is receiving a vasoactive infusion
- ENo, staff without transfer training and competences should not undertake an unsupervised transfer
Show answer
Answer: E
No, staff without transfer training and competences should not undertake an unsupervised transfer
The ICS/FICM guidance requires all staff involved in transfers to be able to demonstrate the competences appropriate to their role, and states that staff without the appropriate training and competences should not undertake unsupervised transfers. It expects staff to receive training in transfer medicine and to gain experience in a supernumerary capacity. A trainee who has never done a transfer and would travel alone meets none of this, however urgent the transfer — urgency is a reason to find a competent escort quickly, not to lower the standard. The patient is also high risk on the guidance's own risk tool (intubated and ventilated, requiring vasopressor support), which calls for a nurse or clinical practitioner plus a doctor or advanced practitioner with critical care and advanced airway competences — so a lone escort is wrong on that ground too. Telephone advice, a checklist or an e-learning module does not make an untrained, unsupervised escort acceptable. The escort need not be a consultant: the tool specifies a doctor or advanced practitioner with the right competences.
Where this comes from
- Guidance On: The Transfer Of The Critically Ill Adult (2019)Intensive Care Society and Faculty of Intensive Care Medicine·10.7 Recommendation 10: competences and unsupervised transfers“Staff without the appropriate training and competencies should not undertake unsupervised transfers.”Open PDF at page 16
- Guidance On: The Transfer Of The Critically Ill Adult (2019)Intensive Care Society and Faculty of Intensive Care Medicine·10.7 Recommendation 9: training and supernumerary experience“have the opportunity to gain experience in a supernumerary capacity”Open PDF at page 16
- Guidance On: The Transfer Of The Critically Ill Adult (2019)Intensive Care Society and Faculty of Intensive Care Medicine·Appendix 7: risk stratification, high risk“Doctor / Advanced Practitioner with critical care”Open PDF at page 36
- Guidance On: The Transfer Of The Critically Ill Adult (2019)Intensive Care Society and Faculty of Intensive Care Medicine·Appendix 7: risk stratification, high-risk criteria“CVS unstable and / or requiring inotrope or vasopressor”Open PDF at page 36